
This update features two very different books about high school athletes. One’s about basketball, one’s about football. One’s a story of kids growing up tough and fighting to get out, one’s a story about an old coach and the town. One’s an amazing piece of writing and among the most touching books I’ve ever read, and one’s a disappointment in comparison.
Let’s start with the latter first so I can just get it out of the way. Our Boys by Joe Drape is the story of the 2008 season for the Smith Center Redmen in Smith Center, Kansas. However, more than that, it’s a piece talking about their legendary coach Roger Barta and the effect he and his team have had on the town.
Now, this isn’t a bad book; I want to make that clear. Drape does a very good job showing how much the town cares for the team (but not in a crazy Texas HS football way), and the lasting effect Coach Barta has on his kids. My problem with it is that I come out of the book feeling like I don’t really know any of the characters.
There is very little conflict or adversity in any of the characters’ lives and we don’t get to see how they react to that. The closest we come is when Joe Osburn, one of the players, goes to Kansas City to visit his birth parents. We don’t anything out of that except that “it wasn’t what he expected.” I’m not asking for Drape to go digging in to a kid’s private life, but that was the only chance in the story to really see how these kids act, feel, and live, and we got nothing out of it.
Contrast this to The Last Shot by Darcy Frey. Now this is how a book about high school athletes should be written. Frey follows four young basketball players at one of New York City’s best public high schools, Lincoln High. Nestled in Coney Island, it’s also one of the city’s worst schools and teaches a lot of students from one of the worst projects in the country.
The story’s four main characters are Russell Thomas (really Darryl Flicking but name changed for legal reasons), Tchaka Shipp, Corey Johnson, and the one and only Stephon Marbury. Starbury, a freshman and the only non-senior in the book, is the last of 4 super-talented Marbury boys to go through Lincoln High, and the family’s last hope at seeing someone go on to the NBA.
Frey dives into the lives these kids lead, exposing the dirty world of college recruiting, the hold basketball has in the projects, the cultural biases in Prop 48 and SATs, and more. It’s amazing and inspiring to see the pride these kids have in what they do and how hard they are trying to just get out of Coney Island.
Make sure you get the 2004 edition of the book with the updated afterword. It’s absolutely heartbreaking, but you really need to know the whole story to appreciate how hard it is for kids in their situation to get ahead in life, no matter how hard they try.
I’ll leave you with two quotes from the book. The first is from Russell (Darryl), the most desperate to get out, about the difficulties growing up in Coney Island.
This is the toughest area to come up in. It really is. ‘Cause once you veer off like them, you’re stuck. Maybe you have another chance, but it’s a little less than you had before. ‘Cause what’s here today can easily fall away.
The second from author Darcy Frey summing up the situation of the kids early in the book.
Never in their lives would they be in possession of so little and on the brink of so much.
If you really want to read about high school football go ahead and pick up Our Boys. But I beg you, please, everybody go buy The Last Shot. I offer you a 100% money-back guarantee that you won’t regret it.